Remorse Burns Like a Sacred Vow Betrayed
Ayodhya Kanda, Doha 144
Doha 144 · Movement 2 of 2
Keep this contemplation
Preserve, print, or share
Imagine a discerning brahmin, learned in sacred knowledge, honored by saints, and born into a noble lineage. If such a person drank wine through mistake, the act would strike at the very identity he had guarded.
Sumantra's remorse carries that intensity. Returning without Ram feels like an accidental violation no explanation can cleanse from memory.
The comparison reveals grief as moral injury. He did not choose betrayal, yet his obedience to Ram's command appears inwardly indistinguishable from abandoning him. The minister bears a shame unsupported by wrongdoing, because devotion judges the empty chariot by love's impossible standard.
Though he obeyed the Lord, Sumantra feels stained as deeply as one who has unknowingly broken the vow shaping his whole life.
Read the passage from the Manas
बिप्र बिबेकी बेदबिद संमत साधु सुजाति। जिमि धोखें मदपान कर सचिव सोच तेहि भाँति।।144।।
A Brahmin of discernment, a knower of the Vedas, honored by saints, born of noble lineage: just as such a man would feel remorse if he drank wine by mistake, so was Sumantra's anguish at that hour.