Abhanga 27 · Verse 2
The Living Nectar of Haripath
लटिका व्यवहार सर्व हा संसार | वायां येरझार हरीविण || २ ||
झूठा है यह सारा व्यवहार, यह सारा संसार | हरि के बिना सब व्यर्थ आना-जाना है || २ ||
All worldly dealings are false, this entire samsara - without Hari, all is pointless coming and going.
latika vyavahara sarva ha sansara | vayan yerajhara harivina || 2 ||
Dnyaneshwar turns to look at everything the Name is not. All worldly dealings, he says, are latika: false, a performance, a promise that does not deliver. This entire samsara, without Hari, is pointless coming and going. He is not condemning the world. He is naming what happens when you live in it without remembrance. The relationship that promised permanence changes. The achievement that promised satisfaction empties. The body that promised health ages. None of this is tragic the way the word is usually used. It is simply what happens when you ask temporary things to be permanent.
If you recognize a tiredness that no holiday can fix, a sense that the treadmill moves but you stand still, this verse has something for you. It does not say try harder or adjust your goals. It says: harivina. Without Hari. The weariness is not caused by the world. It is caused by the absence of the sacred in the world. Let the Name back in. Say Hari while doing the dishes. Say Ram while sitting in traffic. Nothing changes on the outside. Everything changes on the inside.
The Living Words
The verse does not call the world evil. That is the reversal to notice. Dnyaneshwar's word is latika, which is not "untrue" the way a factual error is untrue. Latika is the thing that looks real and has no substance behind the surface. A mirage. A stage set. The polite smile of someone who does not mean it. The world is not a lie. It is a performance that cannot deliver what it appears to promise. And vyavahara, dealings, is his precise diagnosis: the transactional mode, where you give to receive, love to be loved, work to be rewarded. The transactions themselves are not condemned. They are named for what they are. The whole of it, he says, is yerajhara harivina: pointless coming and going without Hari. Two syllables at the end of the line, harivina, drop like a stone into water. The world is not the problem. The world without remembrance is the problem.
Scripture References
This world is fleeting and joyless: having reached it, worship Me.
अनित्यमसुखं लोकमिमं प्राप्य भजस्व माम् ।
anityam asukham lokam imam prapya bhajasva mam
Having come to this fleeting, joyless world, worship Me.
Latika vyavahara, vayan yerajhara: the world is performance and pointless coming-going. Krishna agrees: anityam, asukham. The remedy is the same: bhajasva mam.
Maya is divine and hard to cross; only those who take refuge in Me cross it.
मामेव ये प्रपद्यन्ते मायामेतां तरन्ति ते ।
mam eva ye prapadyante mayam etam taranti te
Those who take refuge in Me alone cross over this maya.
Without Hari, Dnyaneshwar says, there is only false coming and going. Krishna names the same: maya is the false motion; refuge in Him is the only crossing.
Whatever you do, do it as an offering to Me: the world becomes the temple.
यत्करोषि यदश्नासि यज्जुहोषि ददासि यत् । यत्तपस्यसि कौन्तेय तत्कुरुष्व मदर्पणम् ॥
yat karoshi yad ashnasi yaj juhoshi dadasi yat | yat tapasyasi kaunteya tat kurushva mad-arpanam ||
Whatever you do, eat, offer, give, perform as austerity: do it as an offering to Me.
Dnyaneshwar's complaint about samsara is not against the world but against living in it without Hari. Krishna's mad-arpanam reframes every act as devotional.
The Heart of It
This verse sits at the hinge of Dnyaneshwar's farewell. Verse 1 said: all sweetness is in the Name, do not be idle. Verse 2 says: everything else is empty. The two verses are not separate teachings. They are the inside and outside of one observation.
When you taste the sweetness of the Name, the world's offerings reveal themselves as what they always were: temporary, partial, unable to satisfy the deepest hunger. And when you see the world's offerings clearly, the Name's sweetness becomes more vivid by contrast. Each verse illuminates the other.
This is what the tradition calls viveka, discrimination. Not renunciation. Not hatred of the world. Not the grim asceticism that despises beauty and comfort. Simply the capacity to see what lasts and what does not. What feeds and what merely fills. What opens the heart and what clutters it.
Dnyaneshwar is not saying the world is evil. He is saying the world, pursued for its own sake, is latika: it does not keep its promises. The relationship promises permanence and delivers change. The achievement promises satisfaction and delivers hunger for the next achievement. The body promises health and delivers aging. None of this is cruel. It is simply the nature of things that appear in time. They will also disappear in time. To build your happiness on them is to build on something that is already moving.
But here is the key phrase: harivina. Without Hari. The world is not false in itself. It becomes latika when it is pursued without reference to the divine. A meal eaten in remembrance of God is not latika. A relationship conducted in devotion is not latika. Work done as an offering is not latika. What makes the world's dealings false is the absence of the sacred dimension.
Without Hari, even the truest human love is a candle lit in a windstorm. With Hari, even the simplest daily task participates in something that does not end.
Ananta says it plainly: the world is an aspect of God, a reflection of God in a way. But that which we call the meeting with God, the darshan of God, the essence of that darshan, will not be found in worldly things. The world is not the enemy. The world is not enough.
This is not world-denial. This is world-completion. The world becomes real, becomes true, becomes sweet, when it is lived in the presence of the Name. Without that presence, it is what Dnyaneshwar says: pointless coming and going. An oscillation that exhausts but does not nourish.
Rumi, centuries later, used the image of polishing a mirror. The heart reflects the divine, but worldly attachments coat it with rust. The rust is not the mirror's nature. It is what accumulates when the mirror is left unpolished. Remove the rust through remembrance, and the mirror does what it was always designed to do.
The world becomes real when it is lived in the presence of the Name.
The Saints Who Walked This Road
Tukaram knew the falseness of worldly dealings not as a philosophy but as a lived experience.
Before his devotional life began, he was a householder, a shopkeeper, a man embedded in the world's transactions. And the world broke its promises to him systematically. Famine destroyed his livelihood. His first wife died. His child died. The structure of worldly life, which he had trusted, collapsed around him.
From this collapse, he sang. He described being trapped in samsara the way a serpent is trapped in a basket by the music of a juggler: held in place by something hypnotic and false, unable to see the exit. His abhangas return again and again to the vanity of worldly attachment. Not with bitterness. With the clarity of someone who has been burned and is now warning others about the fire.
But Tukaram's genius is that he never stopped being a householder. He did not flee to the forest. He remained in the world, tending his family, navigating his debts. And he chanted. His abhangas say the Name of God was the only thing that did not betray him. Every other promise broke. The Name held.
Namdev arrived at the same insight through a different door. For Namdev, the world's falseness was not discovered through suffering but through vision. He saw God everywhere. And when you see God everywhere, the world's claim to independent reality dissolves. It is not that the tree ceases to exist. It is that the tree is no longer just a tree. It is God in the form of a tree. The world's transactions become transparent. You see through them to what they really are: divine play.
Chokhamela's testimony adds a cutting edge. As an untouchable, Chokhamela experienced the world's vyavahara at its most cruel. The caste system told him he was impure, unworthy, less than human. The transactional logic of purity and pollution, which governed every social interaction, declared his very touch to be contaminating. And he stood at the temple wall, unable to enter, singing to the God inside.
For Chokhamela, the word latika carries a specific and devastating meaning. The system that tells you your birth determines your worth is false. The hierarchy that bars you from the temple is false. The only thing that is not false is the Name that anyone can speak, in any condition, from any position in the social order.
The Refrain
हरि मुखें म्हणा हरि मुखें म्हणा | पुण्याची गणना कोण करी
Say Hari with your mouth, say Hari with your mouth; who can count the merit of this?